The Pure and the Impure

Racking your brain with questions of pure and impure to the point of making them a central, fixed point necessarily leads to rigid behaviors that generate suffering, primarily in those who are hostage to this tropism, then to anyone they encounter.


©FJ Sept. 2025
Recueils / Participation

8 commentaires

      1. « Pure » is absolute. In this life, an ideal, and unattainable.

        « Purity » and « impurity » are antithetical levels by which a… « whatever »… is judged as approximating, or falling short of, the pure.

        But, inevitably, there has to be an understanding of what is « pure » to reach such a conclusion.

        And even the question of what is, or is not, « pure », may prove highly subjective. That seems to me implicit in your post.

        I know of men who judge as pure what I consider corrupt, and as corrupt that which I regard as unobjectionable.

        So, the question of what you consider as « pure », and how you judge « purity », seems to me to be inevitable, in the context of this thread.

        Sorry to hit you with a lawyer’s reasoning.

        Aimé par 1 personne

      2. And yet, the answer is at a different level than this terminological battlefield.
        You are talkingi about purity of the object when I consider purity of the subject.
        The question is not on the « whatever » but on the « whence-ever ».

        When observed from a non pure platform, any object is stained.
        And conversely.

        I agree : Laywer’s reasoning hurts
        Our nature.

        Aimé par 1 personne

      3. And yet, the answer is at a different level than this terminological battlefield.
        You are talkingi about purity of the object when I consider purity of the subject.
        The question is not on the « whatever » but on the « whence-ever ».

        When observed from a non pure platform, any object is stained.
        And conversely.

        I agree : Laywer’s reasoning hurts
        Our nature.

        ___
        second reading : i hadn’t read yoru first line : « « Pure » is absolute. In this life, an ideal, and unattainable. »

        This would be enough to invalidate my point in this comment.
        Except that I still believe this is peremptory. (categorical ?)
        What pertains to the absolute is not so categorically unattaible « in this life ».
        What would we do here, if such were the case …
        I’d stop everything at once.

        Aimé par 1 personne

Répondre à simonashcroft - poet & photos Annuler la réponse.